Peanut Butter Pie
Um…yes. This pie was heaven. Remember how I was obsessing over it for about a week? Well, I not only promised to make it, but I promised to show you pictures and give you a recipe.
I also promised twitter that it would be organic, but that didn’t happen.
First, start with a pie crust. You can use a premade one, like this amazingly delicious and healthy organic whole wheat pie crust from Virginia’s Health Foods…or you can use Joy the Baker’s recipe. Whichever you prefer.
You want to pre-bake that pie crust, so that it is nice and crunchy and flaky before you fill it with the non-bakeables. (Yeah, I made that word up.) Poke holes in the crust and bake for about 10 minutes. Let cool.
Now for the filling. You need 3 things to fill your pie: vanilla pudding (homemade or from a box), peanut butter crumbles (homemade), and whipped cream (if this isn’t homemade, I will punch you in the face).
I tried to make a homemade vanilla pudding, using all organic ingredients, but it never thickened up. Luckily, I had a box of the powdered stuff in the pantry. Prepare your pudding and set in the fridge.
For the peanut butter crumbles, mix about 2/3 cup of crunchy peanut butter with at least a cup of powdered sugar. Mash together until it looks like these crumbles, adding more powdered sugar when necessary.
Now for your whipped cream. You need 2/3 cup cold heavy whipping cream and about 3 heaping tablespoons of powdered sugar. Put both ingredients in a mixer and beat with the whip attachment until light and fluffy. So easy and so gosh darn yummy.
Now all you have to do is put it all together. Here is the order, from the bottom up: pie crust, pb crumbles, vanilla pudding, pb crumbles, whipped cream, pb crumbles.
BAM! Its done. Now get a fork and eat it all by yourself on the couch while watching a Harry Potter marathon. I’m not judging.












